Nothnagel, I. (2009) Conceptual Metaphors in Media Discourses on AIDS Denialism in South Africa

Abstract

According to Nattrass (2007:138), the denial and questioning of the science of HIV/AIDS at government level by, amongst others, Thabo Mbeki (former State President) and Manto Tshabalala-Msimang (former Minister of Health) resulted in an estimated 343 000 preventable AIDS deaths in South Africa by 2007. Such governmental discourse of AIDS denialism has been the target of criticism in the media and by activist groups such as the Treatment Action Campaign. This study investigates the nature of this criticism, specifically considering the critical use of metaphor in visual texts such as the political cartoons of Jonathan Shapiro, who works under the pen name of “Zapiro”. The purpose is to determine whether the nature of the criticism in visual newspaper texts differs from that of corresponding verbal newspaper texts, possibly providing means of criticism not available to the verbal mode alone.
A corpus of texts published between August 1999 and December 2007 that topicalise HIV/AIDS was investigated. This includes 119 cartoons by Zapiro, and 91 verbal articles in the weekly newspaper Mail & Guardian. The main theoretical approach used in the analyses is Conceptual Metaphor Theory, developed by Lakoff and Johnson (1981), and its extension to poetic metaphor, developed by Lakoff and Turner (1989). Because of the socio-political nature of the problem of HIV/AIDS, the study also draws on Critical Discourse Analysis, including complementary concepts from Systemic Functional Linguistics.
The study reveals that visual and verbal texts make use of similar sets of conventional conceptual metaphors at similar frequencies, which confirms the predictions of Conceptual Metaphor Theory. The study further reveals that the cartoons enrich these metaphors through four specific mechanisms of poetic metaphor, which the verbal articles do not. This indicates a significant difference between the two types of texts. Furthermore, it is found that the use of such poetic metaphors directly contributes to the critical power of the political cartoons. The study indicates that multi-modality in cartoons, which triggers single metaphoric mappings, adds a dimension to the critical function of the text that is absent in the verbal equivalent. The finding that the visual texts enable a form of cognition that is not available to verbal texts, poses one of the most significant avenues for future research. Thus, cartoons apparently achieve a type of criticism that is not found, and may not be possible, in the verbal texts alone. This makes the political cartoon a text type with an important and unique ability to articulate political criticism.

Citation Ignatius Nothnagel (2009). Conceptual Metaphors in Media Discourses on AIDS Denialism in South Africa (Master's Thesis, Stellenbosch University, Stellenbosch, South Africa). Thesis

BibTex entry for this thesis:

BibTex entry for this thesis:

@phdthesis{nothnagel2009conceptual,
address = {Stellenbosch, South Africa},
author = {Nothnagel, Ignatius},
number = {March},
pages = {1--123},
school = {Stellenbosch University},
title = {{Conceptual Metaphors in Media Discourses on AIDS Denialism in South Africa}},
type = {Master's Thesis},
year = {2009}
}

Table of contents

Chapter 1 - Introduction

  • 1.1 AIDS denialism
  • 1.2 Criticism through political cartoons
  • 1.3 The focus of the research
  • 1.4 Research questions
  • 1.5 Research hypotheses
  • 1.6 Chapter outline

Chapter 2 - Literature Review

  • 2.1 Conceptual Metaphor Theory (CMT)
  • 2.2 CMT Extended: Poetic Metaphor Theory (PMT)
  • 2.3 Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA)
  • 2.4 Systemic Functional Linguistics (SFL)
  • 2.5 CDA & SFL in the visual medium
  • 2.6 CMT and cartoons

Chapter 3 - Research Methodology

  • 3.1 Kind of data
  • 3.2 Collection of data
  • 3.3 Method of analysis

Chapter 4 - DATA ANALYSIS I: CARTOONS AS VISUAL TEXTS

  • 4.2 Roleplayers
  • 4.3 Conceptual metaphors
  • 4.4 Higher order metaphors
  • 4.5 Fantasy metaphors
  • 4.6 Representations of Mbeki and Tshabalala-Msimang
  • 4.7 Use of poetic mechanisms
  • 4.8 Image mapping
  • 4.9 Multimodality in the cartoons

Chapter 5 - DATA ANALYSIS II: METAPHOR IN VERBAL TEXTS

  • 5.2 Conceptual metaphors
  • 5.3 Use of poetic mechanisms
  • 5.4 The critical power of poetic metaphor

Chapter 6 - Conclusion

Key ideas

References in nothnagel2009conceptual

  • anthonissen2001effectivity Anthonissen, C. 2001. On the effectivity of media censorship: An analysis of linguistic, paralinguistic, and other communicative devices used to defy media restrictions. Unpublished Ph.D. Thesis, University of Vienna.
  • barthes2002rhetoric Barthes, R. 2002. The Rhetoric of the Image. In McQuail, D. (ed). 2002. McQual’s Reader in Mass Communication Theory. London: Sage Publications. pp. 289- 298.
  • biberauer1996frightening Biberauer, T. 1996. Frightening or enlightening? An appraisal of the functions of the military metaphor in the aids context. In Stellenbosch Papers In Linguistics (SPIL) PLUS no. 29. Stellenbosch: University of Stellenbosch.
  • botha1994teaching Botha, R.P. 1994. Teaching language with the aid of Rottweilers, sharks and dinosaurs. In Stellenbosch Papers In Linguistics (SPIL) PLUS no. 26. Stellenbosch: University of Stellenbosch. pp. 265-280
  • carroll1996note Carroll, N. 1996. A Note on Film Metaphor. Journal of Pragmatics 26(6): 809-22.
  • el refaie2003understanding El Refaie, E. 2003. Understanding visual metaphor: the example of newspaper cartoons. In Visual Communication 2(1):75-95. London: Sage Publications.
  • forceville1995tuning Forceville, C. 1995. IBM is a Tuning Fork: Degrees of Freedom in the Interpretation of Pictorial Metaphors. In Poetics 23:189-218.
  • fowler1991language Fowler, R. 1991. Language in the News: Discourse and Ideology in the Press. London: Routledge.
  • fowler1979critical Fowler, R. & Kress, G. 1979. Critical Linguistics. In Fowler, R., B. Hodge, G. Kress and T. Trew. 1979.
  • fowler1979language Fowler, R., Hodge, B. Kress, G. & Trew, T. (eds) 1979. Language and control. London; Boston; Henly: Routledge and Kegan Paul. pp.185-213.
  • gombrich1971cartoonists Gombrich, E.H. 1971. The Cartoonists Armoury. In E.H Gombrich (ed) Meditations on a Hobby Horse and Other Essays on the Theory of Art, 2nd edn. London: Phaidon. pp. 127-42.
  • johnson1981philosophical Johnson, M. (ed). 1981. Philosophical Perspectives of Metaphor. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
  • kennedy1993mystery Kennedy, V. 1993. Mystery ! Unravelling Edward Gorey’s Tangled Web of Visual Metaphor. In Metaphor and Symbolic Activity 8(3): 181-93.
  • kennedy1993metaphoric Kennedy, J.M., Green, C.D. and J. Verbaeke. 1993. Metaphoric Thought and Devices in Pictures. In Metaphor and Symbolic Activity 8(3): 243-55.
  • kress1996reading Kress, G. and T. Van Leeuwen. 1996. Reading Images: The Grammar of Visual Design. London: Routeledge.
  • lakoff1993contemporary Lakoff, G. 1993. The contemporary theory of metaphor. In A. Ortony (ed). pp. 202- 251.
  • lakoff1980metaphors Lakoff, G. & Johnson, M. 1980. Metaphors we live by. Chicago: University of Chicago press.
  • lakoff1981conceptual Lakoff, G. & Johnson, M. 1981. Conceptual Metaphor in Everyday Language. In Johnson, M. (ed). 1981. Philosophical Perspectives of Metaphor. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
  • lakoff1989more Lakoff, G. and M. Turner. 1989. More Than Cool Reason: A Field Guide To Poetic Metaphor. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
  • locke2004critical Locke, T. 2004. Critical Discourse Analysis. London: Continuum International Publishing Group.
  • martin2003working Martin, M.R. and D. Rose. 2003. Working with Discourse: Meaning beyond the clause. London: Continuum International Publishing Group.
  • mccloud1994understanding McCloud, S. 1994. Understanding Comics: The Invisible Art. New York: HarperCollins Publishers.
  • mcquail2002mcquails McQuail, D. 2002. McQuails Reader in Mass Communication Theory. London: Sage Publications.
  • morris1993visual Morris, R. 1993. Visual Rhetoric in Political Cartoons: A Structuralist Approach. In Metaphor and Symbolic Activity 8(3): 195-210.
  • nattrass2007mortal Nattrass, N. 2007. Mortal Combat: AIDS Denialism and the Struggle for Antiretrovirals in South Africa. Kwazulu-Natal: University of Kwazulu-Natal Press.
  • preiser2008public Preiser, W. 2008. Public lecture on Clinical research & HIV/AIDS, at Stellenbosch University on 15 October 2008.
  • reddy1979conduit Reddy, M.J. 1979. The conduit metaphor: A case of frame conflict in our language about language. In Ortony, A. (ed). 1993. Metaphor and Thought 2nd edition. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. pp. 164-201.
  • ross1998ethics Ross, J. 1998. Ethics in the language of AIDS. In Pierce, C. and D. van der Veer (eds.) 1998. Ethics and public policy. New York: Wadsworth Press. pp. 39-55.
  • shapiro2008zapiros Shapiro, J. 2008. Zapiros Biography. Zapiro’s Official Website. Online: http://www.zapiro.com (Accessed in August 2008).
  • sontag1991illness Sontag, S. 1991. Illness as Metaphor and Aids and its Metaphors. London: Penguin Books.
  • verwoerd2000truths Verwoerd, W. & Mabizela, M. C. 2000. Truths Drawn in Jest: Commentary on the Truth and Reconciliation Commission Through Cartoons. Cape Town: David Phillip.
  • wodak2001methods Wodak, R. and M. Meyer. 2001. Methods of Critical Discourse Analysis. London: Sage Publications.
  • wolk2007reading Wolk, D. 2007. Reading Comics: How Graphics Novels Work and What They Mean. Cambridge, MA: Da Capo Press.
Keywords:

AIDS, Conceptual Metaphor Theory, Favorite, Forceville, MA in Linguistics, South Africa, Thesis, Zapiro

Print/export